--> I'm Lucky 최근글 <--

'상업용 부동산'에 해당되는 글 3건




  1. 2010.07.24 부동산 활성화 대책, DTI 규제완화 적절한가? 6
  2. 2010.04.15 베이지북 Beige Book 2010년 4월호 _FRB, 미국 경제상황 보고 _10.04.14
  3. 2009.10.22 베이지북 Beige Book 10월호 _FRB 미국 경제상황 보고 _09.10.21

정부가 최근 부동산 거래가 부진하다는 이유로 '부동산 활성화 대책'을 검토했다.

서울 강남권(강남, 서초, 송파)을 중심으로 아파트 거래부진을 이유로 대책이 필요하다는 하소연이 나왔기 때문이다.

물론 언론보도에 따르면, 'DTI 규제완화'를 비롯한 '부동산 활성화 대책'은 청와대 신임 참모진들의 검토 의견에 따라 현 시점에 적절하지 않은 것으로 결정되었다고 한다. 

이런 결론은 매우 당연한 것이다. 그래서 신임 참모들의 의사판단은 적절하다. 

여기서 과연 '부동산 활성화 대책' 운운하는 것이 원론적으로 과연 설득력이 있는지 생각해 보자.


1. 주식 시장 하락한다고 '증시 활성화 대책'을 요구하지 않아

자산(asset) 시장에는 여러 종류가 있다. 그 중에 투자(investment)의 면에서 가장 두드러지는 시장은 당연 주식시장(stock)이다.

그런데 주식시장이 하락한다고 정부에 '증시 활성화 대책'을 요구하지는 않는다.

왜냐하면 주식시장이 상승하고 하락하는 것은 사이클에 따른 시장 본연의 속성이기 때문이다.

비단 주식시장만이 아니라, 가격, 시세가 상승과 하락을 반복하는 것은 모든 자산 시장의 본질적 특성이다. 

부동산 시장도 다르지 않다.

왜 '부동산 시장'만 유독 지속적으로 상승해야 하는가? 왜 부동산 시장의 자산 가격은 하락하면 안되는가?

전혀 이유를 찾아볼 수 없다. 설득력도 없다.

인위적으로 시장을 부양하려 한다면, 결국 시장의 자율적 가격형성 시스템을 거부하여, '시장 경제'를 부정하는 것에 다름 아니다.

물론 주식시장에서도 인위적으로 '증시 활성화 대책'이 시행된 적이 있었다.

1988년 올림픽 이후 증시가 폭락하자, 노태우 정권이 빠져나오기 위해 인위적으로 증시에 자금을 투입했던 것이다.
그런데 그 결과는 어떠한가? 오히려 더 큰 증시 폭락을 불러왔을 뿐이다.

즉 자산의 가격이라는 것은 시장 자율적으로 수요-공급과 적절한 컨센서스에 따라 형성되어야 하는 것이지, 누가 인위적으로 조성해야 하는 것이 아니다. 

DTI 규제 완화 대책도 마찬가지로 볼 수 있다. 시세가 떨어진다고, 대출을 늘려줘서 시세를 부양하자는 생각은 정말로 위험천만한 발상이다.  그런 식으로 시세가 부양될 수도 없고, 일본의 장기불황을 가져온 '양적 완화 정책'의 전철을 밟을 수 있으므로 조심해야 한다.

금리도 변수가 되지 못한다. (차후 글에서 자세히 살펴보겠지만) 현재 금리는 2.25%로 여전히 너무 낮은 수준이기 때문이다.
금리 이상 수익을 목표로 하는 부동산 임대 수익의 면에서도, 금리 인상이 반드시 '악재'는 아니다.


2. 자산의 가격이 시장 컨센서스(consensus)에 따라 움직이는 것은 매우 당연

위에서 지적한바, 자산 가격(asset price)이 시장 주체들의 일반의사, 컨센서스(consensus)에 따라 항상 움직이는 것은 매우 당연한 현상이다.

모든 자산시장의 시세는 항상 상승하지만은 않는다.

예컨대, 최근 1,000p 박스권을 상향 돌파하여 2,000p도 넘어섰던 국내 코스피(Kospi) 지수는 최근에 900p대까지 하락하기도 했다.
그 이후 이 글을 작성하는 현재, 지수는 1,700p대 중반에 위치해 있다.

이게 근 3년래에 모두 일어난 일이다.

세계 상품(commodity) 시장에서도 동일한 현상을 관찰할 수 있다.
 
국제 금시세가 최근에 3배 이상 상승하기도 했는가 하면, 반대로 국제 유가는 고공행진과 급락 과정을 반복하고 있다.

마찬가지다.

부동산시장도 항상 상승하지만은 않는다. 그런 '편견', '왜곡'(bias)된 시선을 깨야 한다.

주택시장, 아파트시장도 마찬가지라는 것이다.

도대체 주택가격, 아파트가격이 지속적으로 상승한다고 보는 '보증수표'가 어디에 있는가?


3. 부동산, 주택 시장을 '임대'가 아닌 '투기'로 변질시킨 것은 시장 주체 자신의 책임

모든 자산시장의 가격 상승에는 원리(Logic)가 있다.

그 원리는 무엇인가? 바로 '부가가치'(value-added)에 대한 '기여'이다.

자산은 그 자체로는 '소유권'의 증명 이외에는 큰 가치가 없다.

아무리 시가총액이 많이 나가는 회사라도, 좋은 제품을 만들어서 매출을 올리지 못하고, 지속적으로 영업 적자를 내면 그대로 무너져서 '휴지조각'이 되는 사례도 많다.

국제 철(Fe) 가격이나 구리(Cu) 가격이 상승하는 이유는 산업 생산 과정에서 수요량이 높아지고 있기 때문이다.

부동산, 주택 시장도 마찬가지라는거다.

부동산이든 주택이든 '건축물' 그 자체로는 아무 가치가 없다. 왜냐하면 그 자체로는 아무런 '부가가치'를 만들어낼 수 없기 때문이다.

상업용 부동산이든, 주거용 부동산이든 그 안에서 사람들이 활동하면서 '부가가치'를 만들어내는 '터전'이 되기 때문에 '시세'가 유지될 수 있는 것이다.

따라서 단순히 부동산이기 때문에 시세가 유지되야 한다거나, 거래가격이 지속적으로 상승해야 한다는 어떠한 당위성도 없다.

그렇다면 부동산의 가장 큰 수익의 원천은 무엇인가?

그것은 '소유'(property)가 아니라, '임대'(rent) 수익이다.

왜냐하면 '소유'는 '소유자' 자신에게 기여해야 하지만, '임대'는 '임차인'의 '부가가치' 창출에 기여하는 보상이기 때문이다.

그게 바로 아파트 가격이 지속적으로 상승할 수 없는 이유, 아파트 시세가 전반적으로 하락할 수 있는 이유이기도 하다.

소유자 자신에게 큰 '부가가치'를 줄 수도 없으면서, '임대'의 수요도 떨어지고, 임대의 '가치'도 떨어진다면 당연히 시세는 하락해야만 한다. 그게 시장 매커니즘의 자율적인 작동이기도 하다.

애초에 주택시장은 소유하면서 시세 상승을 노리고 '투기'하는 '투기 상품'이 아니었다.

그런데 1990년대 들어서면서 언론지를 중심으로 마치 '아파트'나 '주택'이 투자 상품인 것처럼 버젖이 등장하기 시작했다.

1980년대 전두환 정권 시절에는 감히 상상할 수 없는 일이었고, '복부인'이라고 불리는 일부세력에 의해 사회적인 비난을 감수하며 은밀하게 이뤄지던 일이었다.

그런데 이런 시각이 일부 언론지들의 잘못된 호도에 의해 마치 아파트가 '투자'의 대상인 것처럼 비쳐지면서, 주거용 부동산 시장의 자산 거품이 생겨나기 시작한 것이다.

부동산 투자자들이 '부동산'에 투자해야 하는 이유는 '부동산'이 엄청난 투자 수익을 가져오기 때문이 아니다.
'부동산'은 산업생산이나 업무활동에 기여하면서 '부가가치' 창출 활동에 기여, 그 보상으로 '임대 수익'을 가져다 주기 때문이다.

즉 경제가 안정적이라면, '물가상승률'이나 '시장 이자율'을 비트(beat)할 수 있는 소규모로 약간 우월한 임대 수익을 바라보고 투자하는 것이다. 그게 '부동산 투자'(real estate investment)의 원론이기도 하다.

특히 '사업용 시설'이 아닌 '주거용 시설'인 경우에는 말할 필요가 없다. 

마치 '아파트'를 '투기'의 장으로 만들어온 것은 일부 시장 주체 자신들의 책임이라는거다.

사업용 시설은 경제가 활황이면 시세가 크게 상승할 수도 있으나, 주거용 시설은 모든 인간이 누려야할 주거권의 대상이기 때문에, 시세가 급상승한다는 거 자체가 말이 되지 않는다. 하기에 '전세, 월세'를 중심으로 하는 '임대형' 수익 이외에 '자산 가격'의 급상승을 주거용 시설에서 바라는 것은 애초에 말이 안된다.



4. 주택 부동산 시장 가격 정상화 과정

결국 강남권(강남, 서초, 송파) 아파트를 중심으로 주거용 부동산 시세가 하락하는 것은 매우 당연한 현상이다. 
(이는 차후에 보다 세밀한 면에서 살펴보기로 한다.)

왜냐하면 위에서 지적한 바, 주거용 부동산 시장은 애초에 '투기' 대상의 시장이 될 수 없기 때문이다. 
그런 자산 가격 상승을 지탱해줄만큼 '투자형 아파트'는 '부가가치'를 담보하지 못하기 때문이다.  

아파트의 과도한 가격상승을 용인하고 입주해야할만큼, 아파트 입주자에게 그만한 '부가가치'가 돌아오지 않는다는거다.



원론적으로도 그렇다.

건축물은 인간이 그곳을 기반으로 활동하지 않는다면, 콘크리트에 불과한 것이다.

과수원의 과실은 매년 '열매'라도 가져오지만, 건축물은 활용되지 않으면 어떤 '부가가치'도 가져다주지 못한다.

지난 20년간 '부가가치'를 무시하고, '가격 상승'만이 나타난 아파트 시장의 전반적인 대세 하락은 자명하다는 것이다.

그것은 시장 매커니즘이 요구하는 향후의 흐름이기도 한다. 

그래서 주택 부동산 시장은 현재 정상화 과정에 있다고 지적한 신임 청와대 참모진들의 주장은 충분히 설득력이 있다. 


5. 부동산 시장의 특성 - '임대' 수익 위주의 '부가가치'  

앞서 말했듯이 부동산 투자의 기본은 '투기'가 아니라 안정적인 '임대' 수익이다.

부동산이 가치를 지니는 것은 그것이 상업, 사업, 주거의 기반으로 작용하면서 다른 '부가가치'의 창조 활동을 돕기 때문이다.

단순히 부동산을 소유하기만 하면, 시세가 급상승하고, 대세상승할거라고 기대하는 것은 '착오'다.

특히 강남권역의 '아파트'에서는 그런 '환상'을 빨리 깨버려야 한다. (다음 글에서 자세히 논함)

또한 '토지'와는 다르게 '아파트'는 지속적인 감가상각의 대상이 된다.
실수요 주거용으로 '소유'하는 것이라면, 감가상각을 자신의 부가가치 창출 경제활동으로 삭감하겠지만,
'임대'를 위해 소유하고 있다면, 그런 '아파트 투기'가 과연 적절한 수익을 가져다 줄지 심각히 생각해 봐야 한다.

물론 '토지'도 '개발비용'과 '부지특성'이 반영되기 때문에, 감가상각이 없다고 마냥 소유할 일이 아니다. 

부동산이 대세상승할 것처럼 투자에 나서는 그런 '투기적 시각'을 이제는 되돌아볼 필요가 있다는 것이다.

특히 상업용, 사업용 시설도 아닌 주거용 '아파트' 시장에서는 더욱 그러하다. 

결론적으로, '부동산 거래 활성화 대책' 운운하며 정부가 인위적으로 시세에 관여하는 정책은 바람직하지 않다.
모든 자산시장은 자율적으로 시세의 상승과 하락을 반복하기 때문이다. 





맞춤검색

,

2010년의 세번째 베이지북인 4월호 'Beige Book'이 4월 14일(현지) 미국에서 발표되었습니다.

베이지북(Beige Book)은 미국의 경제상황, 경기동향을 보여주는 대표적인 경제지표로 미국 연방준비은행(FRB, Federal Reserve Bank)가 연간 8회 작성하여 공개합니다.

2010녀 4월호는 올 해의 3번째 베이지북으로, 1월 13일, 3월 3일(현지)에 각각 1, 2호가 발행된 바 있습니다.

이번 4월호 보고서의 주요 내용을 보면,

"지난 보고서 이후로 모든 지역의 경제 활동의 개선되고 있다. (세인트루이스 제외) 
소매 판매와 자동차 판매도 늘어나고 있고, 관광산업도 개선되고 있다.
제조업 경기도 개선세에 있다.

주택착공과 주거용 부동산 시장을 비롯한 주택 경기, 건설 경기도 개선의 조짐이 보인다.
반면에 상업용 부동산은 여전히 약세에 머물러 있다.

노동시장은 여전히 약세이지만, 임금 상승 압박은 최소한에 머물러 있고,
소매 물가도 여전히 안정적이다."

위와 같은 내용으로 보고하여, 미국의 경기가 전 지역에서 개선세를 보이고 있음을 분명하게 했습니다. 



* 전미경제조사국(NBER, National Bureau of Economic Research)는 2007년 12월부터 미국 경제가 '침체기'에 빠져들었다고 이미 선언한 바 있는데, 아직까지 '회복세'로 전환했다고 밝히지 않았습니다. 그런데 해당 자료에 의하면, 미국의 1945년부터 2001년까지 '경기 침체기'의 평균 지속기간은 10개월이라고 하는데, 현재의 침체 기간은 벌써 28개월이 넘어서고 있습니다.
(관련글, 미국 경제 침체기의 평균 지속기간)

그래서 NBER이 미국 경제침체기의 종료를 공식 선언할 날도 얼마 남지 않은거 같네요.

이러한 영향으로 미국 다우지수(다우존스 지수, DJIA)는 이날 큰 폭으로 올랐습니다.



베이지북(Beige Book)은 미국 지역 연방은행들이 수집한 미국 12개 지역의 경기동향을 요약한 자료입니다.
이 자료는 미국 경제상황과 동향을 실시간으로 보여주는 핵심지표로 FRB가 직접 발표합니다.

이들 12개 지역을 보면, Boston, New York, Philadelphia, Cleveland, Richmond, Atlanta, Chicago, St. Louis, Minneapolis, Kansas City, Dallas, San Francisco 입니다. (보스톤, 뉴욕, 필라델피아, 클리브랜드, 리치몬드, 아틀란타, 사카고, 세인트루이스, 미네아폴리스, 캔사스시티, 댈라스, 샌프라시스코)

다음 베이지북은 2010년 6월 9일(미국 현지)에 발표됩니다.

한편, 국내의 경우에도 코스피 지수가 먼저 움직인 감은 있으나, 2010년 연초의 시초가 1700p 부근에 4월 초반의 지수도 머물러 있기 때문에, 앞으로 연간 고점을 향해서는 여전히 상승의 폭이 열려있다고 볼 수 있겠습니다.

[관련글] 
주식시장 지수 변동성의 이해  /  주식투자 몇 월부터 하는게 좋을까?  /  주식투자 반드시 해야 하나? 
이효리 주식 투자 실패, 연예인 주식투자 10개 지침


첨부 : FRB 베이지북 2010년 4월호 보고서 요약 전문 (2010.04.14 Beige Book)

Summary 요약

Prepared at the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis and based on information collected before April 5, 2010. This document summarizes comments received from business and other contacts outside the Federal Reserve System and is not a commentary on the views of Federal Reserve officials.

요약 전문

Overall economic activity increased somewhat since the last report across all Federal Reserve Districts except St. Louis, which reported "softened" economic conditions. Districts generally reported increases in retail sales and vehicle sales. Tourism spending was up in a number of Districts. Reports on the services sector were generally mixed. Manufacturing activity increased in all Districts except St. Louis, and new orders were up. Many Districts reported increased activity in housing markets from low levels. Commercial real estate market activity remained very weak in most Districts. Activity in the banking and finance sector was mixed in a number of Districts, as loan volumes and credit quality decreased. Agricultural conditions were mixed as well, with positive conditions reported in Districts from the central and western parts of the country, while negative conditions were reported in the mid and southern Atlantic Districts. Mining and energy production and exploration increased for metals, oil and wind.

While labor markets generally remained weak, some hiring activity was evident, particularly for temporary staff. Wage pressures were characterized as minimal or contained. Retail prices generally remained level, but some input prices increased.

세부 항목

Consumer Spending and Tourism  소비자 소비, 관광
District reports indicated that consumer spending increased during the reporting period. New York and Cleveland reported that recent sales strengthened, while sales rebounded in Richmond and Kansas City. Slight sales gains were reported in Philadelphia. Retail sales in San Francisco continued to improve, but remained somewhat sluggish on net. In St. Louis several new establishments opened, particularly in the food industry. Several Districts described consumers as somewhat more confident. Businesses were cautiously optimistic regarding future sales: Cleveland, Atlanta, Kansas City and Dallas noted that retailers expect sales to improve during the upcoming months. Sales of home furnishings and electronic goods increased in a number of Districts, while seasonal apparel sales were up in New York, Philadelphia and Kansas City. New York and Minneapolis noted that shopping by Canadians was strong at businesses near the border. Atlanta reported that retailers continued to keep inventory levels lower than normal, and retailers in New York reported that inventories are in very good shape.

Vehicle sales improved in a number of Districts during March. New York, Philadelphia, Atlanta, Chicago, St. Louis, Minneapolis, Dallas and San Francisco noted that auto sales picked up in recent weeks. Cleveland described sales as decent, while sales were steady in Kansas City and mixed in Richmond. Several Districts noted that favorable pricing and credit terms helped lure buyers into showrooms. Dealers in Philadelphia indicated that they expect sales to increase during the next few months.

Tourism conditions also improved during the reporting period. New York, Richmond, Chicago, Minneapolis, Kansas City, Dallas and San Francisco pointed to signs of increased tourism activity. Tourism was described as stable in most parts of the Atlanta District. Hotel occupancy rates were rising in New York, Chicago, Kansas City, and San Francisco. Reports on room rates were mixed: New York and Kansas City noted increases, while Chicago reported rate cuts, particularly at luxury hotels. Managers at mountain resorts in the Richmond District reported that this winter was one of their best ski seasons ever. However, Atlanta noted that corporate bookings remained at very low levels at some high-end resorts.

Nonfinancial Services  비농업 서비스
Business services were mixed, with some signs of economic recovery. Boston and Minneapolis reported increased activity. Richmond and Dallas were mixed, while San Francisco said demand remained lackluster. St. Louis reported that the sector continued to decline. Advertising and consulting firms in Boston said demand is up substantially from the first quarter of 2009, while an advertising contact in Richmond and professional media services firms in San Francisco characterized sales as flat at low levels. Dallas reported sluggish demand for nontax-related accounting and legal services. Law firms in Minneapolis specializing in debt collections and bankruptcy saw strong demand, while a Richmond property manager noted a large number of repossessions.

Manufacturing   제조업
Manufacturing activity increased since the last report across most of the country, with all Districts other than St. Louis reporting increases in orders, shipments, or production. Boston, Cleveland, Chicago, Dallas and San Francisco reported positive results in metals and fabrication. Cleveland, Richmond, Atlanta and Chicago reported increased auto or auto component production. Boston, Richmond, Dallas, and San Francisco saw increased production in electronic, computers or high-technology goods. Chicago and Minneapolis saw increased production of energy-related products. However, for construction-related goods, Chicago and Dallas reported mixed conditions, Boston reported flat activity and St. Louis reported decreases. Overall, St. Louis saw more plant closures than plant openings.

Banking and Finance   은행 금융 
Bank lending activity was mixed by category in most Districts. Atlanta, St. Louis and Kansas City saw weaker loan demand across categories, while activity in San Francisco was flat at low levels and Dallas said that demand appears to be stabilizing. Demand for consumer credit decreased in New York and increased slightly in Philadelphia. Most banks in Cleveland reported weak consumer loan demand, although a few contacts saw a slight increase due to seasonal factors. Business and industrial loan volumes decreased in Philadelphia, Cleveland and Chicago and were flat in New York. San Francisco noted continued modest gains in venture capital funding.

Credit standards remained generally unchanged across the nation, while credit quality was mixed. New York, Cleveland and Kansas City reported tighter lending standards for commercial mortgages. In Atlanta several business contacts reported difficulty getting credit. Dallas and San Francisco said standards continued to be tight. New York saw increased delinquency rates for all categories except consumer loans, which were flat. Philadelphia and Richmond saw little change in credit quality, while Cleveland was mixed. Dallas reported that credit quality was either stabilizing or improving, and appeared to have turned a corner. Chicago noted an improvement in consumer and business loan quality, although credit quality for many small firms continued to decline.

Real Estate and Construction  부동산 건설
Residential real estate activity increased, albeit from low levels, in most Districts, with the exceptions of St. Louis, where it was mixed, and San Francisco, where it was flat. Contacts in Philadelphia, Cleveland and Kansas City expressed concern about whether sales would continue to grow after the expiration of the first-time home buyer tax credit. New York, Kansas City, Dallas and San Francisco noted sluggish sales for high-end homes. Home prices were stable across most Districts, but decreased in parts of the New York and Atlanta Districts. Residential construction activity increased slightly in New York, Atlanta, St. Louis, Minneapolis and Dallas, but remained weak in Cleveland, Chicago and San Francisco.

Commercial real estate activity was slow across the nation. Notable exceptions were Richmond, which saw an uptick in commercial leasing, and Dallas, where the sector was mixed and might be nearing bottom. In Boston, leasing activity consists largely of renewals, with many renewing tenants leasing less space. Manhattan Class A office rents were down 20 percent to 25 percent year over year. Contacts in Philadelphia, Richmond, Kansas City and Dallas expressed concern that lease concessions from landlords were putting downward pressure on rents. Commercial construction continued to be weak in most Districts. Cleveland saw some development in the energy and industrial segments.

Agriculture and Natural Resources  농업 천연자원
Districts reported mixed results in agriculture. Atlanta reported that cold weather negatively affected crop conditions. Richmond, Kansas City, and Dallas noted that wet conditions delayed planting, though Dallas also commented that current soil moisture levels will be beneficial for the growing season. Chicago expected a normal planting schedule. Minneapolis and San Francisco indicated favorable weather conditions. The calving season is doing well in the Minneapolis District, but Chicago and Minneapolis noted softening dairy output prices.

Activity in the energy and mining sectors increased since the last report. Philadelphia, Atlanta, Minneapolis, Kansas City, Dallas and San Francisco saw increases in oil exploration. Coal production was mixed in the Philadelphia District and increased in the Kansas City District. In the Minneapolis District, more wind energy projects are planned, and mining activity increased.

Employment, Wages, and Prices  고용, 임금, 물가
While overall labor markets remained weak, some hiring activity was evident, particularly for temporary staff. Employment in the manufacturing and services sectors in Boston remained relatively unchanged, while very little hiring occurred at major legal and financial firms in New York. In the Richmond District, job cuts subsided at retail businesses, and employment was stable at most other services firms. In Kansas City overall employment levels held steady, but more manufacturers and several energy-related firms planned to increase payrolls. Cleveland, Richmond, Atlanta, and Chicago reported strong demand for temporary workers. A pickup in employment was noted in the manufacturing sector by Cleveland, with little change in staffing for retail, energy, transportation and banking. Atlanta noted that many businesses continued to increase hours worked for existing staff. Minneapolis reported that while labor markets remained weak, some signs of hiring were noted.

Wage pressures were characterized as minimal or contained. In Boston, most firms reported instituting or planning to institute modest wage increases of 2 percent to 3 percent in 2010, while performance bonuses in the services sector were generally down. Richmond reported that average wages edged higher in March in the services sector, but declined slightly in manufacturing. Most companies hiring new workers in the Kansas City District were not offering higher salaries to attract qualified applicants. Dallas reported that just a handful of firms were planning on partially reinstating employer matches to retirement plans or giving small pay increases. In Chicago wage pressures were minimal; however, an increase in health-care costs was noted. San Francisco also reported significant increases in the costs of employee benefits, such as health insurance and pensions.

Retail prices generally remained level, but some input prices increased. Where producers faced cost pressures on inputs, they were largely unable to pass those prices downstream to selling prices, although in Kansas City some manufacturers were considering raising selling prices due to higher raw materials costs. In Boston retail vendor and selling prices were stable. Philadelphia reported that prices of most goods and services have been steady, although there were increased reports of rising prices for basic materials and construction-related products. Apart from rising prices for steel and petroleum-based products in Cleveland, raw materials and product pricing were generally stable. Richmond noted moderate price increases in the manufacturing and services sectors. Chicago reported upward pressure on prices for plywood, industrial metals and petroleum-based fuels. In the Dallas District prices of chemicals and related products rose sharply, primarily due to plant outages. Natural gas prices slipped during the reporting period because of continued high levels of production, low industrial demand and the end of the winter season. Richmond and San Francisco reported increased overseas shipping costs.

2010
January

13

HTML

273 KB PDF


February


March

3

HTML

925 KB PDF


April

14

HTML

683 KB PDF


May


June

9



July

28



August


September

8



October

20



November


December

1



2010 | 2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 | 2002 | 2001 | 2000 | 1999 | 1998 | 1997 | 1996

1970 - present (on the web site of the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis)



맞춤검색

,


미국 FRB의 베이지북 Beige Book, 2009년 10월호가, 10월 21일(현지) 발표되었습니다.
베이지북은 미국의 경제상황, 경기동향을 보여주는 중심지표로 연간 8회 작성, 공개되는데, 2009년 7번째에 해당합니다.
2009년 마지막 베이지북 발표는 2009년 12월 2일로 예정되어 있습니다.

이번 베이지북에서 FRB는 보고서 작성의 기초 대상이 되는 연방 12개 지역에서 경기는 안정화와 개선세가 나타나고 있다고 밝혔습니다. FRB는 지난 9월 9일 베이지북에서 미국 경기가 "개선세를 보이고 있다"고 이미 분명하게 밝힌 바 있습니다.

이번 보고서에서는, 주택용 부동산 시장과 제조업의 개선세가 확연해지고 있다고 지적했습니다.
반면에, 상업용 부동산 시장은 여전히 가장 침체한 부분으로 지적하고 있습니다.

물가와 임금상승 압박은 크지 않은 가운데, 안정적인 수준을 계속 유지하고 있다고 합니다.

베이지북(Beige Book)은 지역 연방은행들이 수집한 미국 각 12개 지역의 경기동향을 요약한 자료로,
미국 경제상황을 보여주는 핵심지표로 작용하며, 연방준비은행 FRB, Federal Reserve Bank가 발표합니다.

이들 12개 지역은 Boston, New York, Philadelphia, Cleveland, Richmond, Atlanta, Chicago, St. Louis, Minneapolis, Kansas City, Dallas, San Francisco 입니다. (보스톤, 뉴욕, 필라델피아, 클리브랜드, 리치몬드, 아틀란타, 사카고, 세인트루이스, 미네아폴리스, 캔사스시티, 댈라스, 샌프라시스코)



첨부 : FRB 베이지북 보고서 전문 파일(2009.10.21 Begie Book)

Summary


Prepared at the Federal Reserve Bank of Richmond and based on information collected before October 13, 2009. This document summarizes comments received from businesses and other contacts outside the Federal Reserve and is not a commentary on the views of Federal Reserve officials.

전문요지

Reports from the 12 Federal Reserve Districts indicated either stabilization or modest improvements in many sectors since the last report, albeit often from depressed levels. Leading the more positive sector reports among Districts were residential real estate and manufacturing, both of which continued a pattern of improvement that emerged over the summer. Reports on consumer spending and nonfinancial services were mixed. Commercial real estate was reported to be one of the weakest sectors, although reports of weakness or moderate decline were frequently noted in other sectors.

Reports of gains in economic activity generally outnumber declines, but virtually every reference to improvement was qualified as either small or scattered. For example, Dallas cited slight improvements residential real estate and staffing firms, while New York noted gains only in a few sectors (predominantly manufacturing and retail). Retail and manufacturing conditions were mixed in Boston, but some signs of improvement were reported. New York, Philadelphia, Cleveland, and San Francisco cited small pickups in manufacturing activity. In the Kansas City District, an uptick was noted in technology firms, while services firms posted revenue gains in Richmond. However, conditions were referred to as stable or flat for business services and tourism firms in Minneapolis and agriculture in St. Louis and Kansas City.

The weakest sector was commercial real estate, with conditions described as either weak or deteriorating across all Districts. Banking also faltered in several Districts, with Kansas City and San Francisco noting continued erosion in credit quality (often with more expected in the future). One bright spot in the banking sector was lending to new homebuyers, in response to the first-time homebuyer tax credit. Finally, labor markets were typically characterized as weak or mixed, but with occasional pockets of improvement.

Districts generally reported little or no increase to either price or wage pressures, but references to downward pressures were occasionally noted. While upward price pressures were generally subdued in most Districts, materials prices increased in Cleveland (mainly for steel) and Kansas City. Manufactured goods prices were flat to up slightly in Boston. Boston reported that in some market segments "product competition and customer clout are leading to downward pressure on prices." Minimal wage pressures were noted in Cleveland and Minneapolis.


부문별 내용

Consumer Spending and Tourism  소비 지출, 여행
Consumer spending remained weak in most Districts since the last report, although some improvements were noted. Chicago reported a continued decrease but at a slower rate than in the previous reporting period, and retailers maintained low inventories. Richmond reported flat or declining sales; Dallas indicated sales were largely unchanged. However, Dallas reported unexpected weakness at value-based retailers. Sales were mixed, according to Boston, St. Louis, and Kansas City, with Kansas City citing strong sales of cold weather apparel and lower-priced goods. San Francisco remarked that sales were little changed, with the exception of an increase in furniture sales. Although New York observed weak sales in upstate New York, general merchandise retailers in the City were ahead of plan and same-store sales were roughly on par with a year earlier. Boston noted that large-scale retailers had cut inventory due to weak sales. Philadelphia saw a pickup in back-to-school shopping. Cleveland observed that consumers were very price-sensitive and inventories were lean; nonetheless, sales were flat or slightly improved.

The "cash-for-clunkers" program ended in August, leaving depleted inventories and slower sales in its wake. New vehicle sales declined in New York, Philadelphia, Cleveland, Richmond, Atlanta, Minneapolis, Kansas City, Dallas, and San Francisco. However, Chicago reported a pick-up in vehicle sales in early October. Low new-car inventories helped to move used cars in several Districts, although San Francisco commented that the demand for used cars also weakened. New York also reported that automobile dealers saw some improvement in credit conditions for consumers looking to purchase cars.

Looking to expectations for holiday sales, Chicago anticipated improved sales, while Philadelphia retailers expected consumers to limit spending. However, Third District merchants also noted that store traffic increased recently. Atlanta reported that two-thirds of contacts expected flat or declining sales over the next three months.

Tourist activity varied across Districts. Boston, New York, and Atlanta described business travel as extremely soft, whereas Richmond observed solid growth in group bookings. Occupancy rates held steady in New York, spurred by increased leisure visitors, while aggressive discounting boosted cruise-line occupancy rates in Atlanta. San Francisco reported a deep slide in hotel and resort visits in Southern California and Las Vegas, but noted a continued firming of occupancy rates in Hawaii. Richmond indicated overall bookings were much improved over last year, while Kansas City reported occupancy rates remained below year-ago-levels. Room rates continued to decline in several Districts, including New York and Atlanta. In contrast, Boston said that hotels were offering dramatic promotional deals and discounts on local attractions, which preserved posted room rates.

Nonfinancial Services  비금융 서비스
Nonfinancial services firms had mixed reports in recent weeks. Kansas City observed increased demand for high-tech services and Richmond noted generally increased revenues, particularly in telecommunications and healthcare services. Demand for healthcare services also picked up in the Boston District. Minneapolis observed that activity in nonfinancial services firms was mostly flat at low levels, although technology consultants reported an uptick and competition heated up among engineering firms. In contrast, San Francisco contacts indicated that demand for services in general fell, and elective medical procedures were being deferred. St. Louis noted that revenues declined at several large firms in business support services.

Transportation services activity generally declined, although Cleveland and Chicago reported some strengthening. Atlanta observed weak transportation demand overall, and firms in the San Francisco District indicated that trucking had declined. Import demand in the Dallas District fell, leading to a reduction in cargo volumes at intermodal firms. Activity in the transportation sector was flat, according to Kansas City. In contrast, the cash-for-clunkers program helped to clear dealership lots, which prompted dealers to restock their depleted inventories and drove up car shipments. Chicago reported that trucking shipments increased, although the level of activity remained low, and Cleveland's contacts cited an uptick in freight transport volume in recent weeks. Cleveland also noted that trucking companies planned substantial equipment purchases through the first quarter of 2010. Business travel by air declined since the last report, according to San Francisco, while airlines in the Dallas District reported stabilized demand--albeit at low levels.

Manufacturing  제조업
Most Districts reported that manufacturing activity was generally stronger since the last report. New York, Richmond, Minneapolis and Kansas City all noted a further pickup in production, while Philadelphia, Cleveland, Chicago and San Francisco mentioned slight-to-moderate increases. Growth rates varied by industry, however, and some Districts experienced little or no overall increase. Boston reported that manufacturing activity was mixed, but had stabilized or shown modest improvement in certain industries. Similarly, Dallas said overall demand in manufacturing was flat at weak levels albeit with pickups in the high-tech, food, and petrochemical industries. St. Louis indicated that manufacturing continued its net decline, and Atlanta noted moderate declines in orders and production. Some Districts (Boston, Richmond and Chicago) mentioned that year-over-year drops in new orders of housing-related products had abated. Cleveland, Richmond, and Chicago reported substantial increases in auto and parts production, which were attributed primarily to restocking dealers' and manufacturers' inventories. Accordingly, lean inventories and stronger demand from the auto sector led to an increase in steel production in the Cleveland and Chicago Districts.

Comments on the near-term outlook varied across Districts. Boston, Philadelphia, Cleveland, and Kansas City reported that their contacts expected only slight gains and modest economic growth during the next six months. Therefore, capital spending plans remained subdued, and centered mostly on new product development or cost reduction. Dallas indicated that planned projects and routine maintenance were being deferred to conserve capital. New York, however, reported that respondents were increasingly optimistic about the near-term outlook and expected to hire more workers and spend more on capital.

Real Estate and Construction  부동산, 건설
Most Districts reported that housing market conditions improved in recent weeks, primarily from a pickup in sales of low- to middle-priced houses. Contacts reported that sales were boosted by the government's tax credit for first-time homebuyers. Resale activity also edged up in parts of the New York District, although prices continued to be depressed due to a substantial volume of foreclosures and short sales. New and existing home sales remained flat in the Philadelphia District, and home sales continued to decline throughout the St. Louis District. Sales of higher-priced homes were very slow, according to Philadelphia, Cleveland, and Kansas City. Moreover, real estate agents in the Boston and Cleveland Districts were uncertain about the future of home sales once the tax credit expires. Availability of financing continued to be a concern for potential buyers in the Cleveland and Chicago Districts.

Residential construction activity remained weak in most Districts. Atlanta reported that construction remained very low, and Cleveland expected new home construction to proceed at a slow pace. Chicago indicated that construction on existing developments edged up, but St. Louis reported that construction activity declined. Kansas City reported that housing starts stabilized, although levels remained well below a year ago and were not expected to improve over the next three months. Philadelphia noted that builders continued to offer increased incentives to boost sales.

Commercial real estate continued to weaken across the 12 Districts, although even this sector had scattered bright spots. Each District indicated that demand for private commercial real estate was weak, with New York, Philadelphia, Cleveland, Atlanta, Chicago, St. Louis, Kansas City, and San Francisco all characterizing activity as declining further since the last report. An inability to obtain credit was often cited as a problem for businesses that wanted to purchase or build space. High vacancy rates were noted as a key concern especially for landlords who were not offering concessions. And, while industrial real estate in the Richmond District was generally weak, renewed interest by retailers to revisit postponed expansion plans was also noted. Finally, public nonresidential construction activity funded by federal stimulus projects was a source of strength in the Cleveland, Chicago, Minneapolis, and Dallas Districts, but gains were often offset by state and local government cutbacks.

Banking and Financial Services  은행, 금융 서비스
Many Districts continued to report weak or declining loan demand, and many noted further erosion of credit quality. For example, demand was reported as stable or declining by New York, St. Louis, and Kansas City. Cleveland noted that commercial and industrial lending was soft and consumer lending was flat or reduced. In the Richmond District, modest signs of improvement in consumer loans were cited from banks in areas typically supported by the health care and education industries. Philadelphia also reported a small gain in consumer lending. San Francisco said that loan demand was "largely stable or perhaps rose slightly." A major exception to the general pattern of weak or declining lending activity was in residential real estate. Most Districts cited the federal government's first-time homebuyer program as supporting residential lending activity. However, Dallas reported that residential mortgage demand was disappointing, and St. Louis mentioned a moderate decline in real estate lending.

Credit quality continued to be a problem, and rising delinquencies were often noted. For example, credit quality was described as stable or declining in the Philadelphia, Cleveland, and Kansas City Districts. Half of the contacts for Kansas City expected loan quality to continue to erode over the next six months. Cleveland stated that the quality of loan applicants had deteriorated somewhat, mostly on the business side. Delinquencies were also widely reported to be up; New York particularly noted rising delinquency rates among both consumer and commercial mortgage loans.

Employment, Wages, and Prices  고용, 임금, 물가
Labor market conditions were generally reported as weak or mixed across Districts, but a few encouraging signs were noted. Employment activity was soft in the Kansas City District, and hiring remained limited in the Boston District. While a slowdown in layoffs was reported by Atlanta, no hiring was generally expected. Reports from Cleveland were mixed, but indicated declining employment in commercial construction and coal mining. Employment levels held steady in the Dallas District, with scattered reports of layoffs. However, staffing firms there noted improvement in contract and temporary employment. Minneapolis reported a weak labor market, but some signs of improvement were noted among auto-related industries. A major New York employment agency specializing in office workers reported renewed softening in recent weeks, with only scattered hiring at financial institutions and virtually no hiring in the legal and publishing industries. Richmond noted reports from temporary employment agencies were evenly mixed between reports of strengthening and weakening, but with increased optimism for the near term expressed since the last report.

Wage and price pressures were generally described as subdued across most Districts. Wages were flat in the San Francisco District, but increased moderately in the Minneapolis District. In the Boston District, business services firms (mainly advertising and consulting) reported modest salary increases, but a decline in bonuses left total compensation slightly reduced. Wage pressures were characterized as "not significant" in the Chicago District and "contained" in the Cleveland District.

Prices followed a similar pattern to wages, with reports of little significant pressure on either input or output prices, although moderate increases were observed for materials prices. For example, prices movements were characterized as generally subdued or little changed in the Philadelphia, Atlanta, and Minneapolis Districts. Cleveland noted stable construction materials prices, but added that the cost of steel had experienced an uptick. Materials prices in general were reported to be up in the Kansas City District. Boston said that selling prices of manufacturing goods were flat to slightly up, but noted that product competition and consumer clout was leading to downward pressures in some market segments. Retail price inflation slowed slightly in the Richmond District, while retail prices were stable in the Philadelphia District and edged down in the Chicago, Kansas City, and San Francisco Districts.

Agriculture and Natural Resources  농업, 천연자원
Assessments of agricultural activity were mixed. Reports from Richmond and Minneapolis indicated that favorable growing conditions allowed farmers to make steady progress in harvesting summer crops and planting winter crops. In some parts of the Minneapolis District, however, a persistent drought delayed harvesting. In contrast, Atlanta, Chicago, St. Louis, and Dallas Districts all noted unusually high amounts of rainfall. In the Atlanta District, floods damaged some of North Georgia's nurseries, vegetable farms, and commercial vineyards, but benefited Florida citrus growers. Similarly, widespread rains brought much-needed relief to drought-stricken parts of the Dallas District, allowing many ranchers to scale back costly supplemental feeding--but not in time to prevent severe losses to livestock and crops. Chicago and St. Louis mentioned that wet weather had slowed crop maturity and harvesting, while Chicago reported lower than expected yields. Kansas City indicated that, despite some delayed harvests, farmers expected above-average yields.

Activity in the energy industry remained weak. Atlanta, Kansas City, Dallas, and San Francisco reported increases in oil and gas inventories as demand continued to weaken. Atlanta indicated that refining margins continued to deteriorate, which led to delays in new projects. Cleveland noted that sharply lower contract prices for coal prompted coal miners to continue their deep cutbacks in production and to keep their capital spending on hold. Kansas City mentioned that overall drilling activity improved slightly, but that rig counts were still at historically low levels. Dallas remarked that rig counts rose in September and early October, spurred by oil drilling. However, Dallas also indicated that, despite the increase, excess capacity in the industry had resulted in job losses and weak domestic pricing. Minneapolis reported that activity in the energy and mining sectors increased slightly and noted that oil and gas exploration inched up in late September.


2009
January

14

HTML

183 KB PDF


February


March

4

HTML

187 KB PDF


April

15

HTML

253 KB PDF


May


June

10

HTML

232 KB PDF


July

29

HTML

276 KB PDF


August


September

9

HTML

166 KB PDF


October

21

HTML

289 KB PDF


November


December

2



2009 | 2008 | 2007 | 2006 | 2005 | 2004 | 2003 | 2002 | 2001 | 2000 | 1999 | 1998 | 1997 | 1996

1970 - present (on the web site of the Federal Reserve Bank of Minneapolis)

[관련글]
2009-09-09 미국 베이지북 2009년 9월호


맞춤검색

,

(★ 검색으로 결과를 얻어보세요. Let's Search ★)



--> I'm Lucky 최근글 <--